Convergence and complete continuum in Plato's philosophy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
6 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The main aim of this article is to defend the thesis that Plato apprehended the structure of incommensurable magnitudes in a way that these magnitudes correspond in a unique and well defined manner to the modern concept of the Dedekind cut. Thus, the notion of convergence is consistent with Plato's apprehension of mathematical concepts, and in particular these of density of magnitudes and the complete continuum in the sense that they include incommensurable cuts. For this purpose, I discuss and interpret, in a new perspective, the mathematical framework and the logic of the Third Man Argument (TMA) that appears in Plato's Parmenides as well as mathematical concepts from other Platonic dialogues. I claim that in this perspective the apparent infinite sequence of F-Forms, that it is generated by repetitive applications of the TMA, converges (in a mathematical sense) to a unique F-Form for the particular predicate. I also claim and prove that within this framework, the logic of the TMA is consistent with that of the Third Bed Argument (TBA) as presented in Plato's Republic. This supports Plato's intention for assuming a unique Form per Predicate; that is, the Uniqueness thesis.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)185-222
Number of pages38
JournalFar East Journal of Mathematical Sciences
Volume83
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Continuum
Predicate
Logic
Well-defined
Uniqueness
Converge
Philosophy
Concepts
Form
Framework

Keywords

  • Complete continuum
  • Convergence
  • Infinity
  • Platonic philosophy

Cite this

@article{af505544f26a47cf9d3a1f3eebdfa55b,
title = "Convergence and complete continuum in Plato's philosophy",
abstract = "The main aim of this article is to defend the thesis that Plato apprehended the structure of incommensurable magnitudes in a way that these magnitudes correspond in a unique and well defined manner to the modern concept of the Dedekind cut. Thus, the notion of convergence is consistent with Plato's apprehension of mathematical concepts, and in particular these of density of magnitudes and the complete continuum in the sense that they include incommensurable cuts. For this purpose, I discuss and interpret, in a new perspective, the mathematical framework and the logic of the Third Man Argument (TMA) that appears in Plato's Parmenides as well as mathematical concepts from other Platonic dialogues. I claim that in this perspective the apparent infinite sequence of F-Forms, that it is generated by repetitive applications of the TMA, converges (in a mathematical sense) to a unique F-Form for the particular predicate. I also claim and prove that within this framework, the logic of the TMA is consistent with that of the Third Bed Argument (TBA) as presented in Plato's Republic. This supports Plato's intention for assuming a unique Form per Predicate; that is, the Uniqueness thesis.",
keywords = "Complete continuum, Convergence, Infinity, Platonic philosophy",
author = "George Chailos",
year = "2013",
language = "English",
volume = "83",
pages = "185--222",
journal = "Far East Journal of Mathematical Sciences",
issn = "0972-0871",
publisher = "University of Allahabad",
number = "2",

}

Convergence and complete continuum in Plato's philosophy. / Chailos, George.

In: Far East Journal of Mathematical Sciences, Vol. 83, No. 2, 2013, p. 185-222.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Convergence and complete continuum in Plato's philosophy

AU - Chailos, George

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - The main aim of this article is to defend the thesis that Plato apprehended the structure of incommensurable magnitudes in a way that these magnitudes correspond in a unique and well defined manner to the modern concept of the Dedekind cut. Thus, the notion of convergence is consistent with Plato's apprehension of mathematical concepts, and in particular these of density of magnitudes and the complete continuum in the sense that they include incommensurable cuts. For this purpose, I discuss and interpret, in a new perspective, the mathematical framework and the logic of the Third Man Argument (TMA) that appears in Plato's Parmenides as well as mathematical concepts from other Platonic dialogues. I claim that in this perspective the apparent infinite sequence of F-Forms, that it is generated by repetitive applications of the TMA, converges (in a mathematical sense) to a unique F-Form for the particular predicate. I also claim and prove that within this framework, the logic of the TMA is consistent with that of the Third Bed Argument (TBA) as presented in Plato's Republic. This supports Plato's intention for assuming a unique Form per Predicate; that is, the Uniqueness thesis.

AB - The main aim of this article is to defend the thesis that Plato apprehended the structure of incommensurable magnitudes in a way that these magnitudes correspond in a unique and well defined manner to the modern concept of the Dedekind cut. Thus, the notion of convergence is consistent with Plato's apprehension of mathematical concepts, and in particular these of density of magnitudes and the complete continuum in the sense that they include incommensurable cuts. For this purpose, I discuss and interpret, in a new perspective, the mathematical framework and the logic of the Third Man Argument (TMA) that appears in Plato's Parmenides as well as mathematical concepts from other Platonic dialogues. I claim that in this perspective the apparent infinite sequence of F-Forms, that it is generated by repetitive applications of the TMA, converges (in a mathematical sense) to a unique F-Form for the particular predicate. I also claim and prove that within this framework, the logic of the TMA is consistent with that of the Third Bed Argument (TBA) as presented in Plato's Republic. This supports Plato's intention for assuming a unique Form per Predicate; that is, the Uniqueness thesis.

KW - Complete continuum

KW - Convergence

KW - Infinity

KW - Platonic philosophy

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84893522000&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:84893522000

VL - 83

SP - 185

EP - 222

JO - Far East Journal of Mathematical Sciences

JF - Far East Journal of Mathematical Sciences

SN - 0972-0871

IS - 2

ER -